What did Moore mean by the "Naturalistic Fallacy"? What is "naturalistic" about it? Is it really a fallacy? Has either G J Warnock or Philippa Foot succeeded in establishing the legitimacy of ethical naturalism?
0 User(s) Rated!
0 User(s) Rated! Words: 2471 Views: 12 Comments: 0
"If I am asked, "What is good?" my answer is that good is good and that is the end of the matter. Or if I"m asked, "How is good to be defined?" my answer is that it cannot be defined, and that is all I have to say about it". G.E. Moore, "Principia Ethica" Indeed it does appear that this is all Moore has to say about it. The absence of any acceptable "proof" that his position is more tenable than that of the ethical naturalists or metaphysicians makes it necessary for him to make this point so forcibly....
the end of all action should be the maximum possible fulfilment or pro-interests of everyone concerned which is almost an amalgam of Utilitarianism in society and "self-realisation" in the individual. This is the least limiting definition of goodness or right action covering wide areas of human experience. To enthuse, and quote: "with a few basic definitions, the whole field of; human values including ethics, are organised in such a way that every item now springs into place a frustratingly complex area of inquiry has become simplified and clarified. It achieves unity and gives a naturalist theory in one brilliant stroke"..
the end of all action should be the maximum possible fulfilment or pro-interests of everyone concerned which is almost an amalgam of Utilitarianism in society and "self-realisation" in the individual. This is the least limiting definition of goodness or right action covering wide areas of human experience. To enthuse, and quote: "with a few basic definitions, the whole field of; human values including ethics, are organised in such a way that every item now springs into place a frustratingly complex area of inquiry has become simplified and clarified. It achieves unity and gives a naturalist theory in one brilliant stroke"..
Abstract The research question of this extended essay came across at a very early stage in my life. Having been born and developed from a family with all its members being University instructors and professors, I was often involved in arguments related to the lack of critical thinking in...
Words: 5171 View(s): 16 Comment(s): 0
Fletcher's Situation Ethics is a theory of how to deal with everyday moral dilemmas in a practical manner. Due to the fact that the theory steps away from "textbook morality" it can be seen as immensely practical in everyday situations. Unlike the legalistic approach to ethics which, relies upon...
Words: 1037 View(s): 11 Comment(s): 0
The "ars praedicandi" was literally the "art of preaching" - an elaborate theory which set down the rules and guidelines - both moral and technical - by which all preachers must abide. Chaucer was familiar with the "ars", possibly only because of the many sermons he would have invariably...
Words: 1194 View(s): 6 Comment(s): 0
In Roman times, abortion and the destruction of unwanted children was permissible, but as out civilization has aged, it seems that such acts were no longer acceptable by rational human beings, so that in 1948, Canada along with most other nations in the world signed a declaration of the United...
Words: 4542 View(s): 18 Comment(s): 0







